Reform drdlr, and by the directorate of performance monitoring and evaluation in the presidency, as well as the voluminous academic literature. The land reform policy and its related programmes which aim to provide equitable access to land have gathered strength after 1994 and intend to promote participation and. In each of these countries the process of land reform is incomplete. The challenge of transformation and redistribution. As described in key documents such as the white paper on south african land policy dla. The current status and future of land reform in south africa. A mix of revenge and socialist ideology are behind the expropriation with compensation policy amendments that.
The constitution allows for expropriation of property for a public purpose or in the public interest, subject to just and equitable compensation. Perceptions regarding land reform debate, progress made and challenges encountered in. May 30, 20 land reform has been a failure in every single respect and this failure will haunt south africa for the next 20 years, said prof nick vink of the department of agricultural economics at stellenbosch university, at the recent red meat abattoir association conference in stellenbosch. Government adopted a willing buyer, willing seller approach to land acquisition for purposes of redistribution, and prices paid have generally been around market. Land reform tops the list of priorities affecting south african agriculture, given the current policy environment in which the sector operates. By the cutoff date of december 1998, a total of 63 455 land restitution claims had been lodged. Government will at all times act in the best interest of our nation. Nearly 60% of all south africans, live on land or in dwellings outside of. The presidential advisory panel on land reform and agriculture v. Dr john purchase, ceo of the agricultural business chamber, agbiz, examines current and planned developments in land reform.
It is believed to allow previously unemployed people to participate in the economy and better the countrys economic growth. Although land reform projects were exempt from restrictions of subdivision, in practice large groups of people were expected to operate farms as unitary commercial enterprises, a practice that has continued to date. Land reform has to, must take place in south africa. Land reform will continue to be one of south africas biggest problems south africas youngsters are let down by a lousy education system south africa needs a broader choice of leadership options. The research assistance of lisa gennetian, rene bernier and paul higgins is greatly appreciated. Younger prepared for the special program of assistance donors meeting, september 1994. In south africa, the willing buyer is the landless aspirant farmer under the re. As a result the land reform process in south africa has largely adopted the ideology and guidelines outlined earlier. South africas land reform challenges market news, news.
South africa needs a triple reform to have an even chance of dismantling the social legacy of apartheid. Making land available allows family units to grow crops and support livestock, which results in a more continuous flow of food to households, as well as potential cash income for the purchase of other necessary. Firstly the share of mining in gdp stood at 11% in 1994, but has steadily declined over an eighteen year period to its current 5% in 2012. Solving africas land issues to boost productivity, alleviate. Derek hanekom minister of land affairs table of contents foreword the land affairs white paper sets out the vision and implementation strategy for south africa s land policy. In order to rebuild and transform the economy after years of apartheid regimes economic isolation and financial sanctions which were enforced by the international community, reconstruction and development. Everyday practices in south african land and agrarian reform debate, johannesburg. Land reform in south africa is the promise of land restitution to empower farm workers who now have the opportunity to become farmers and reduce inequality. Land reform in south africa is sinking nelson mandela foundation.
There have been problems and controversies with both policy and implementation of the land reform agenda, which uses redistribution, restitution. Aug 15, 20 why south africa s land reform agenda is stuck. The primary objective throughout has been to redress the gross imbalance in landholding, where more than a third of the population is concentrated in per cent of the land area, and occupy land in insecure and secondary ways. Scheme manual november 1995, any person who complies with the criteria laid down in this. Mar 29, 2016 land reform tops the list of priorities affecting south african agriculture, given the current policy environment in which the sector operates. Feb 26, 2017 south africas land reform policy started out with the aim to fund black peoples acquisition of small pieces of land for smallscale farming and settlement. Land reform a complete failure vink farmers weekly. Fiscal policy in brief fiscal policy is focused on containing the budget deficit and slowing the pace of debt.
In contrast, the minority white population of south africa hold vast. As a result, a threepart, legalistic, demanddriven, marketbased i. But in addressing the injustices of the past, we must not use race as a determinant of who must be beneficiaries of our land reform policies. After 22 years, land reform has barely altered the landscape of south africa, with only 89%. Land policy proposals south african history online. Fight rages over land reform in south africa forbes. South africa and the global south in a more general sense seekings 2008b. South africa successfully held its first democratic elections in april 1994 and the african national congress anc won with a majority vote to head the government of national unity. Our land reform strategy must be informed not by the need to achieve quantitative land targets, but by the objectives to i support a thriving commercial agricultural sector that can protect south africas food security, ii promote emerging smallscale farmers where economically viable, and iii alleviate poverty and support household.
Government will continue to accelerate the pace of land reform within the framework of the constitution of the republic of south africa, respective legislation and according to the rule of law. The national partys land reform programme was simple and predictable i. Soon after the appearance of this groundbreaking legal document it became the stated policy of the african national congress anc government to reform 30 per cent of commercial agricultural land ownership in south africa by 2009, recently revised to 2015. Under president thabo mbeki the emphasis shifted to promoting purchases by bigger black capitalist farmers, say hall and kepe. Centre for landrelated, regional and development law and policy clrdp at the. Diagnostic report on land reform in south africa parliament of. In south africa much of the theoretical research documented in van zyl et al. Key policy implications purely institutionalist explanations cannot explain variations in african statebuilding in the 21st century.
The programme comprises land redistribution, land restitution and land tenure. It also relates to restitution in the form of settling land claims of people who were forcefully removed from. The most systematic land dispossession by the state came into effect after 19. Twenty two years after the transition to democracy and the commencement of land reform, there is a great deal of lived experience to. Land reform in south africa began in 1990 under the leadership of the national party, which introduced its white paper on land reform in 1991. South africas land reform challenges 06 sep 20 land reform in south africa needs to be addressed, but it shouldnt come at the cost of food security or by breaking up economically efficient enterprises. Land policy in south africa makes a strong claim that land reform can decrease poverty levels and improve food security in rural areas. Pdf the need for the current land reform programme arose from the racially discriminatory laws and practices which were in place for the largest part. Why south africas land reform agenda is stuck reliefweb. This section ends with an assessment of the national land reform pilot programme, which aimed to test the policies that emerged from the process above.
Agreements were based on requests from the government to support components of the national land reform programme already laid down in the initial policy document of the rdp 1994 and the white paper on south african land policy dla, 1997. To understand the process of institutionalization, a historical analysis will form the basis for the study of current distributional policies in south africa. Mar 06, 2017 divisions have arisen along familiar lines in the ruling party after the anc last week rejected the effs motion to amend the constitution to allow for the expropriation of land without. Pdf the historical context of land reform in south africa and. The native land act of 19 fn4 apportioned 8% of the land area of south africa as reserves for the africans and. Adverse incorporation and agrarian policy in south africa 3 andries du toit plaas draft 28 segregation and dispossession moved black people off the land and left the lions share of agricultural land in the possession of a tiny white minority of about 60 000 farmers1. This paper is an analysis of papers, reports and legislation that deals with land reform in south africa. South africas development objectives, expressed in the national development plan, rely on achieving higher economic growth and using public resources effectively. This study focuses on the role that land reform policies have played and are continuing to play in promoting womens sustainable development in south africa.
President donald trump touched off a diplomatic row with south africa by repeating an erroneous broadcast about land reform there. The progress of land reform in south africa 1994 2008. Even so, land reform remains an issue in namibia and the process does experience problems. Secondly, state support for agriculture was deeply skewed. Adverse incorporation and agrarian policy in south africa.
Land redistribution for agricultural development 2001. South africas land reform in historical perspective. Public policy making in a postapartheid south africa. After 22 years, land reform has barely altered the. Land reform was high on the agenda when the african national congress came into power in 1994, but the countrys commitment to an orderly legal process has slowed redistribution.
Human needs, land reform and the south african constitution. In short, the share of mining in national output has more than. A preliminary perspective 11 of redress, reconciliation, nation building, reconstruction, redistribution and growth, and indeed a holistic and integrated process in which political and economic forces interact in dynamic and diverse ways to improve the living standards of the people. The national party land reform in south africa began in. Jun 29, 2016 what has gone wrong in south africas land reform programme, and how can its failings be addressed. Post settlement challenges for land reform beneficiaries. Women, land and livelihoods in south africas land reform programme liepollo lebohang pheko policy brief policy and analysis programme number 1 july 2014 introduction since 1994, the government has moved at a ponderous pace towards land restitution. Perceptions regarding land reform debate, progress made and challenges encountered in redressing land reform were also analysed and discussed. South africas land reform policy started out with the aim to fund black peoples acquisition of small pieces of land for smallscale farming and settlement.
Land reform is probably one of the most difficult domestic policy issues to be dealt with by zimbabwe, namibia, south africa and australia. Land reform in south africa is a moral, social and economic imperative. More than two decades after the end of apartheid in south africa, the unequal distribution of land remains. South africa suffered a long history of colonization, racial domination and land dispossession that resulted in the bulk of the agricultural land being owned by a white minority.
Land redistribution in south africa parliament of south. Land reform in south africa konradadenauerstiftung. General land reform principles 1 the principles in this section shall apply throughout the republic of south africa to the. But the policy is also about economics south africas unemployment rate has been rising and now is more than 27 percent, a rate higher than anything suffered by the u. Zimbabwe, on one side of the spectrum, is facing a crisis in democratisation due to its radical approach to land reform. Although dispossession of black people initially took place through conquest and trickery, it came to be a major policy of the state supported by an array of laws. What has gone wrong in south africas land reform programme, and how can its failings be addressed. Inadequate and inappropriate planning, and lack of meaningful consultation with beneficiaries, gives rise to negative community dynamics, a. The framework for land reform policy was set out in the white paper on south african land policy, released by the department of. Land reform key for south africa economic stability, anc says. The analysis shows that land reform in south africa is slow, mainly due to financial, infrastructural and capacity challenges. Land reform in south africa getting back on track may 2008 cde executive summary this is an executive summary of cde research no 16, land reform in south africa. Acknowledgement that land reform in south africa is necessary, even though a complex and emotive subject.
The promise and peril of south african land reform bloomberg. Apr 07, 2015 even so, land reform remains an issue in namibia and the process does experience problems. New public management and public sector reform in contemporary south africa ivor chipkin and barbara lipietz 1 a version of this article will be published as a chapter in a book edited by the london school of economics and published by palgrave, forthcoming in 2012. Between 1994 and 2011, south africa transferred over 6. Introduction what is going wrong in south africas postapartheid land reform programme, and how can its failings be addressed.
In 1992, the world bank initiated a report on the agricultural sector in south africa. Land reform will continue to be one of south africas. Donors did not set the agenda for land reform in south africa. This article analyzes debates over tenure reform policy in postapartheid south africa, with a particular focus on the controversial communal land rights act of 2004. Restitution seeks to restore land ownership or compensate those who were forcibly removed during apartheid. Mar 24, 2017 solving africas land issues to boost productivity, alleviate poverty and eradicate hunger. We hope it will stimulate interest in the fulllength report, in which the issues and recommendations briefly described here are discussed in depth. Section 25 5 provides that the state must take reasonable legislative and other measures, within its available resources, to foster conditions which enable citizens to gain access to land on an equitable basis. Padayachee, 2000, economic policy and power relations in south africa s transition to democracy, world development, vol. On restitution projects, the maintenance of production has been. Mar 09, 2017 south africas ruling party will accelerate the transfer of land to the black majority to help reduce inequality and avert future protests, the african national congresss spokesman zizi kodwa. In 2008 kas partnered with the southern african development community. Tenure reform is directed towards two distinct objectives. This transformation included all major facets of the public sector including organisational and personnel reforms.
651 606 979 264 920 623 86 1026 989 719 184 1307 770 965 1487 779 595 421 1102 852 440 71 1185 45 1437 490 893 548 186 13 1235 424 133 924 165